IMDB Bottom 100: Number 2 - Saving Christmas

Number 2: Saving Christmas (2014)

So, let’s talk about Kirk Cameron.

Cameron was a child actor who first shot to fame in the eighties playing Mike Weaver in US sitcom Growing Pains, for which he received two Golden Globe nominations and has worked steadily since. But no one cares about that. The thing they care about most is that he is a Christian.

Being apatheist myself, this is of no interest to me but seems to make a lot of people very angry. If you do a google search of Kirk Cameron, beyond the standard IMDB/Wikipedia profile pages, all the results centre around his Christian beliefs.

Which brings us to Saving Christmas. The poster has Kirk Cameron in action movie pose. A big sell for what is essentially a seventy-minute Bible studies lesson.

So, it starts with Cameron sitting in his living room, sipping his hot chocolate (reports of marshmallows unconfirmed), talking about how much he loves Christmas for four minutes and hates all the people who run it down as a commercialised, pagan festival. I’m getting Ed Wood flashbacks, imagining Kirk Cameron as Crisswell.

Film starts proper and Kirk is at a Christmas party. Snow falling all around him, children playing, having fun. It’s the season of love and understanding. Merry Christmas everyone!

And we have Kirk narrating the story. Great.

There is a problem though, Kirk’s brother in-law Christian. He (gasp!) doesn’t like Christmas. He leaves the party to sit in his car and mope. Christian (played by director Darren Doanne, who looks a bit like Bryan Cranston, ‘I am the one who prays’) tells Kirk it’s because he doesn’t see the Christianity in the season. It’s a celebration of materialism and paganism, Baby Jesus has been pushed into the corner (No one puts Baby Jesus in the corner!).

Kirk counters this by telling him about the Nativity and its significance for Christian’s. Which is all well and good and I’m sure would be reaffirming for a Christian but doesn’t actually address Heisenberg’s complaint about Jesus being pushed to the side.

Then Heisenberg moves on to the Christmas tree as a symbol of pagan worship. Kirk explains the tree (and Jesus) as a symbol of light for the world. He also links Adam eating the apple in the Garden of Eden to Jesus’s crucifixion, which may be a bit of a stretch but I’ll go with it. Kirk doesn’t disprove anything Walter White said, just puts his own interpretation on it. Which is all you need in this movie.

That brings us to Santa Claus, the big evil. Everything wrong with Christmas, the one all the kids are worshipping. If you rearrange the letters in Santa, you get Satan. But you know, ‘God’ spelt backwards is ‘Dog’. Or Santa is just the Spanish word for ‘Saint’.

Kirk counters by telling him the story of the real Saint Nick but apparently to do that it needs to be done ‘Lord of the Ringsy.’ Which apparently means lots of slow-motion and broody walking.

Saint Nikalaos of Myra was a key figure in the early years of the Church. Some accounts of him have him dropping gifts for the poor via their chimneys, probably the basis of the Santa mythos. Surprisingly, the film makes little mention of that focusing instead on the Nicaea Council in 325. Even in those early years there were splits in the Church and the Nicene Creed was the document that confirmed Jesus as God made man. Not everyone agreed, such as Arius of Alexandria. So what did Jolly Saint Nick do? He beat the shit out of him, that’s what. I don’t know if ‘believe what I do or I’ll thump you’ is really the message the film should go for but there you have it: Santa Claus, defender of the faith and professional ass-kicker.

Now what this has to do with Santa advertising Coca-Cola, I don’t know.

That’s enough for Walter who gives up the meth business and embraces the Christmas spirit. He charges back to the party, slides across the floor and joins the Christmas party. Kirk Cameron saved Christmas. Not that it was ever really in much danger in the film, I suspect the tile is supposed to be a broader message of preserving the seasons ‘true’ message.

So, that’s it…oh wait, it’s still going on. Of course, Walter still needs to make up with Skyler for being such a jerk. Kirk pauses the action to ask if he should make up with her by being give her a kiss but instead we get an impromptu dance number. The joke would have worked better without the break. On reflection, they should have just gone with the kiss because the dancing is stupid. They're good dancers and all, it’s just so out of nowhere it just feels weird. Still, if you ever wanted to see Kirk Cameron do the Worm, this movie is for you.

An upbeat number like that means the end of the film…what? This is still going on? You took that Lord of the Rings thing too literally. Four minutes sitting round a table eating dinner (by the way, this is supposed to be a party at Kirk’s sisters house and she’s cooked a full Christmas dinner for all her guests which looks like at least thirty people. No wonder she looks so exhausted in all her scenes) and Kirk narrates that all this commercialism is good and what God wants us to do. Hmm, maybe but I would be sceptical of anyone who says they know what an omniscient, omnipresent deity wants from us.

Now the film actually ends and we get a gag reel in the credits, including the director asking if water or celery is better for a dry mouth. Hilarious. Post-credit scene is two minor characters beat-boxing. Marvel, you need to up your game.

I don’t like to shit on anyone’s beliefs and I don’t doubt for a moment part of the reason for the films low rating is Kirk Cameron’s Christianity but as a film Saving Christmas doesn’t really work. Cameron makes a lot of points about the symbolism of Christmas that may strike chord with any Christians watching but in-film don’t address the questions being asked. Cameron may have his interpretation of the Christmas tree as being a symbol of Jesus but that doesn’t make his brother-in-law necessarily wrong for interpreting it as a symbol of pagan ritual. But I don’t want to get into that, enough blood has been spilt over the existence or non-existence of a God or Gods and I don’t want to add to it here.

On a technical level, it’s competent enough. No crazy jump-cuts or weird angles to complain about. And actually, some of the imagery is really quite good. Tonally it’s a bit weird though. Going from light and jovial to deep and serious back to a guy complaining they need to fight to keep ‘Crazy Shirts Friday.’ If I could describe this film in a word, it would be ‘weird.’ Which is not a word I was expecting to use. The opening credits have a ska version of 'Silent Night'. Ska has a high tempo, high energy beat. This is not that kind of film.

I don’t necessarily hate this film. I like that they do try to have an upbeat message about the season even if I don’t agree with all the points they make. I don’t think it’s as terrible as many make out but I’d say it’s misguided.